
12th November 2011, 10:26 PM

#1 (permalink)
 Experienced SGClubber
Posts: 1,634
Join Date: Dec 2009 Likes: 21
Liked 39 Times in 26 Posts
Gender: 
Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
i don't understand (a).
(b) i used geometric series and got the answer "1". but the answer sheet gave me "0.5"... can someone tell me if i am the 1 who got it wrong or is the answer wrong?
as for this question, i used ratio test and there are 2 possible answer as it approaches infinity due to the (1)^n..... and as far as i can remember, if ratio test fails, doesn't it also mean that root test would fail?
Sponsors:
Last edited by KiLlErDeViL; 13th November 2011 at 12:52 AM.

 
13th November 2011, 12:32 AM

#2 (permalink)
 Experienced SGClubber
Posts: 2,404
Join Date: Jul 2009 Likes: 0
Liked 211 Times in 174 Posts
Gender: 
Re: Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
I will settle 4(a) for you first.
Two ways to find this converging limit:
Method 1: As n tends towards infinity, X{n+1}=X{n}
Hence we have X{n}=(1/3) [ 2* X{n}+ 5/( X{n}^2) ]
Do some manipulation, you should end up getting (X{n})^3 =5
ie limit is simply cube root of 5 which is 1.7099759
Method 2: Interpret the recurrence relation as a curve with equation
y=(1/3)[ 2x+ 5/(x^2) ]. Differentiate both sides wrt x and set dy/dx=0.
You will also get the same answer.
Note that so long as the starting term x1 is positive, when you cycle it through numerous iterations of the recurrence relation, all subsequent terms will also remain positive (you might want to graph the curve out to convince yourself) ; in the end it will ALWAYS converge to the minimum point of the curve y=(1/3)[ 2x+ 5/(x^2) ]. So it doesn't matter if X1=1 or X1=10000; ultimately the series will still converge to 1.7099759. (X1 is merely an insignificant token value)
Hope this helps. Peace.
Last edited by whitecorp; 13th November 2011 at 12:33 AM.

 
13th November 2011, 12:37 AM

#3 (permalink)
 Addicted SGClubber
Posts: 362
Join Date: Jun 2007 Likes: 1
Liked 2 Times in 2 Posts
Gender: 
Re: Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
What course are you taking?
For (a) it is a recurrence series.
As for (b) the answer will not be 0.5 since when k=1, the term is 0.5 and the other term are nonnegative. (Or ur telling me that ratio test should yield r=0.5 ? )
For qn 2, it is a GP but it will be easy to evaluate if you split the sum into the sum of having k divisible by 2 and k not divisible by 2.

 
13th November 2011, 01:16 AM

#4 (permalink)
 Experienced SGClubber
Posts: 1,634
Join Date: Dec 2009 Likes: 21
Liked 39 Times in 26 Posts
Gender: 
Re: Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
Originally Posted by whitecorp I will settle 4(a) for you first.
Two ways to find this converging limit:
Method 1: As n tends towards infinity, X{n+1}=X{n}
Hence we have X{n}=(1/3) [ 2* X{n}+ 5/( X{n}^2) ]
Do some manipulation, you should end up getting (X{n})^3 =5
ie limit is simply cube root of 5 which is 1.7099759
Method 2: Interpret the recurrence relation as a curve with equation
y=(1/3)[ 2x+ 5/(x^2) ]. Differentiate both sides wrt x and set dy/dx=0.
You will also get the same answer.
Note that so long as the starting term x1 is positive, when you cycle it through numerous iterations of the recurrence relation, all subsequent terms will also remain positive (you might want to graph the curve out to convince yourself) ; in the end it will ALWAYS converge to the minimum point of the curve y=(1/3)[ 2x+ 5/(x^2) ]. So it doesn't matter if X1=1 or X1=10000; ultimately the series will still converge to 1.7099759. (X1 is merely an insignificant token value)
Hope this helps. Peace. correct me if i am wrong in understanding it
Method 1:
because n going towards infinity, even if n+1 = infinity + 1, where infinity + 1 is still infinity. tat's why you put "X{n+1}=X{n}"
Method 2:
other than this question which you use differentiation, am i allow to use this method to solve all other recursive questions? else, under what situation am i allow to use this method?
so does that mean that in any question, if they give me X1= 1 or any positive value, it would just tell me that all subsequent terms are positive? and if they gave me X1=1, all terms are negative? and so what happens if it is negative?

 
13th November 2011, 01:25 AM

#5 (permalink)
 Experienced SGClubber
Posts: 1,634
Join Date: Dec 2009 Likes: 21
Liked 39 Times in 26 Posts
Gender: 
Re: Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
Originally Posted by Icystrike What course are you taking?
For (a) it is a recurrence series.
As for (b) the answer will not be 0.5 since when k=1, the term is 0.5 and the other term are nonnegative. (Or ur telling me that ratio test should yield r=0.5 ? )
For qn 2, it is a GP but it will be easy to evaluate if you split the sum into the sum of having k divisible by 2 and k not divisible by 2. electrical and electronics engineering (EEE).
qn2: wad u mean by split? you mean like this?
the 2 possible answers are as followed:
L = 2^1 = 2 >1 , therefore diverge
L = 2^3 < 1, therefore converge
so which is the answer? how am i suppose to choose from it?
Last edited by KiLlErDeViL; 13th November 2011 at 02:27 AM.

 
13th November 2011, 11:28 AM

#6 (permalink)
 Addicted SGClubber
Posts: 362
Join Date: Jun 2007 Likes: 1
Liked 2 Times in 2 Posts
Gender: 
Re: Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
For Method 1: We assume that the series is convergence. Therefore, x_{n}=x_{n+1} for some n (>=) N.
For Method 2: It generally holds for "most" series since the series must not be monotone increasing or decreasing (lead to divergence) but a infinite points within (L+e,Le). But the above statement is not a proof, I would recommend you to stick to method 1.
For b, it is not a GP and are you using ratio test to proof its convergence or you are trying to evaluate the sum?
For question 2, what I meant was to evaluate k=2m and k=2m1 for m=1,2,3,... and splitting the sum.
Last edited by Icystrike; 13th November 2011 at 11:32 AM.

 
13th November 2011, 12:09 PM

#7 (permalink)
 Experienced SGClubber
Posts: 1,634
Join Date: Dec 2009 Likes: 21
Liked 39 Times in 26 Posts
Gender: 
Re: Series and Sequence (convergence and divergence)
Originally Posted by Icystrike For Method 1: We assume that the series is convergence. Therefore, x_{n}=x_{n+1} for some n (>=) N.
For Method 2: It generally holds for "most" series since the series must not be monotone increasing or decreasing (lead to divergence) but a infinite points within (L+e,Le). But the above statement is not a proof, I would recommend you to stick to method 1.
For b, it is not a GP and are you using ratio test to proof its convergence or you are trying to evaluate the sum?
For question 2, what I meant was to evaluate k=2m and k=2m1 for m=1,2,3,... and splitting the sum. thx for the explanation.
for b, what is GP? geometric? for b, i am trying to evaluate the sum, not just testing for its convergence
qn 2, i haven't tried the method that u have mentioned, but by letting k=2m and k=2m1, what test am i using? what kind of answer would it determine that its converges or diverges? e.g, L>1 = converge? L<1 = diverge?

   Thread Tools   Display Modes  Linear Mode   